ATTENTION:
BEFORE YOU READ THE ABSTRACT OR CHAPTER ONE OF THE PROJECT TOPIC BELOW, PLEASE READ THE INFORMATION BELOW.THANK YOU!
INFORMATION:
YOU CAN GET THE COMPLETE PROJECT OF THE TOPIC BELOW. THE FULL PROJECT COSTS N5,000 ONLY. THE FULL INFORMATION ON HOW TO PAY AND GET THE COMPLETE PROJECT IS AT THE BOTTOM OF THIS PAGE. OR YOU CAN CALL: 08068231953, 08168759420
WHATSAPP US ON 08137701720
PRIVATE SECURITY COMPANIES AND CRIME PREVENTION IN ABUJA MUNICIPAL COUNCIL
ABSTRACT
This study is focused on the private security companies and crime prevention in Abuja Municipal. The study identified methods of providing security needs of Abuja Residents during the traditional era and through this, factors that necessitate the establishment of PSCs in Nigeria. This study also evaluate the effectiveness of PSCs in their security functions, it also highlight major constraints of the PSCs in carrying out their functions and project strategies for overcoming their constraints for efficient service delivery especially as it affects PSCs and the police. The hypotheses were tested using chi-square (x2). Hypothesis I revealed that the presence of guards/PSCs has reduced crime in the society which further corroborates hypothesis
II that both the guards and subscribers feel satisfied with the services provided by these companies. And Hypothesis III which revealed that trained guards are more effective than those not trained emphasized the need for adequate training of PSCs/guards for the purpose of securing the society.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Certification … … … … … … … … … i
Dedication … … … … … … … … … ii
Acknowledgement … … … … … … … … … iii
Abstract … … … … … … … … … iv
Table of Contents … … … … … … … … … v
Acronyms … … … … … … … … … x
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background to the Study … … … … … … … 1
1.2 Statement of the Research Problem … … … … … … 5
1.3 Research Questions … … … … … … … 8
1.4 Objectives of the study … … … … … … … 8
1.5 Significance of the Study … … … … … … … 9
1.6 Operationalisation of concepts … … … … … … 9
CHAPTER TWO: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
2.1 Review of Empirical Studies … … … … … … 11
2.1.1 The Establishment and Growth of the Private Security Sector in Africa (Nigeria) 14
2.1.2 Evaluation of the Effectiveness of PSCs … … … … … 16
2.1.3 Major Constraints of the PSCs … … … … … … 17
2.2 Theoretical Literature … … … … … … … 18
2.3 Review of Relevant Theories … … … … … … … 20
2.4 Theoretical Framework … … … … … … 23
2.5 Hypotheses of the Study … … … … … … 24
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Research Design … … … … … … … 25
3.2 Area of the Study … … … … … … … 25
3.3 Population and Scope of the Study … … … … … … 26
3.4 Sample Size … … 27
3.5 Sampling Method … … … … … … … … 28
3.6 Instruments for Data Collection … … … … … … 29
3.7 Administration of Instrument … … … … … … … 30
3.8 Method of data analysis … … … … … … … 30
CHAPTER FOUR: DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS
4.1 Data Presentation and Analyses … … … … … … 31
4.2 Questionnaires for Guards … … … … … … 31
4.2.1 Age Range of Respondents …. … … … … … 31
4.2.2 Educational Qualification of Respondents … … … … … 32
4.2.3 Marital Status of Respondents … … … … … … 32
4.2.4 Sex of Guards … … … … … … … … 33
4.2.5 Companies Involved in the study and frequency of Representation … … 33
4.2.6 Local Government Areas of Service … … … … … … 34
4.2.7 Guards Working Duration … … … … … … 34
4.2.8 Number of Guards Posting … … … … … … … 35
4.2.9 Training and Retraining of Guards … … … … … … 35
4.2.10 Relationship of Guards to their Boss (host) … … … … … 36
4.2.11 Do you think the Presence of Guards has Reduce Criminal Activities
in Nigeria State … … … … … … … … 36
4.2.12 Reason for the growth in number of PSCs … … … … 37
4.2.13 Do guards meet their personal basic needs on the job … … … 37
4.2.14 Unable to meet basic needs on the job … … … … … 38
4.2.15 Other jobs assign to guards … … … … … 38
4.2.16 Types of errand guards undertake … … … … 38
4.2.17(a) Directors/supervisors visitation to duty posts … … 39
4.2.17(b) Things directors/supervisor check … … … 39
4.2.18 Problems of Guards … … … … 40
4.2.19 Guards and criminal encounter … 40
4.2.20 Response of guards to criminal activity … … … … … 41
4.2.21 Guards reasons for establishing PSCs … … … … … 41
4.2.22 Methods of providing security during the traditional era in Abuja Municipal … 42
4.2.23 Guards opinion on level of subscribers’ satisfaction … … … 43
4.2.24 Relationship between PSCs and Nigeria police … … … … 43
4.2.25 Do guards prosecute cases in court … … … … … 44
4.2.26 Level of satisfaction with the PSCs services … … … … 44
4.2.27 Suggestion for overcoming problems of the companies … … … 45
4.3 Questionnaire for supervisors/beneficiaries … … … … … 45
4.3.1 Age range of beneficiaries … … … … … … … 45
4.3.2 Educational background of subscribers/beneficiaries … … … 46
4.3.3 Marital Status of Respondents … … … … … … 46
4.3.4 Occupation of beneficiaries … … … … … … 46
4.3.5 Religious Affiliation of Respondents … … … … … 47
4.3.6 Local Government Areas of Respondents … … … … … 47
4.3.7 Area/Streets of Sampled Residents … … … … … 48
4.3.8 PSCs Engaged … … … … … … … … 49
4.3.9 Types of Residence … … … … … … … 49
4.3.10 Duration of engagement … … … … … … … 50
4.3.11 Increase/growth in number of PSCs will lead to reduction in crime activities 50
4.3.12 Reasons for reduction of criminal activities … … … … 50
4.3.13 Level of satisfaction with services of PSCs by subscribers … … … 51
4.3.14 Reasons for PSCs establishment … … … … 51
4.3.15 Means of obtaining security before emergence of PSCs … 52
4.3.16 Other duties assigned to guards … … … … 52
4.3.17 Other benefits derived from PSCs by their host communities 53
4.3.18 Would you consider your security guards as well trained 53
4.3.19 Major problems of guards/PSCs … 54
4.3.20 Possible suggestions to improve service delivery of the PSCs in Abuja Municipal 54
4.3.21 Do you feel more secured with guards … … … … … 55
4.3.22 Reasons why they feel more secured with guards … … … … 55
4.4.0 Test of Hypotheses … … … … … … … 56
4.4.1 Hypothesis one … … … … … … … 56
4.4.2 Hypothesis two … … … … … … … … 57
4.4.3 Hypothesis three … … … … … … … … 58
4.5.0 In-depth interview schedule for directors/supervisors … … … 59 ………………………………..
4.5.10 Duration on duty for the guards………………………………………………………………………….. 62
4.5.11 Factors responsible for the increase in PSCs … … … … 62 ………………………………………..
4.5.13 Factors Necessitating the Establishment of PSCs…………………………………………………….. 63
4.5.14 Achievement of your PSCs … … … … 63 ………………………………………………………………
4.5.15 Major constraints of the PSCs…………………………………………………………………………….. 64
4.5.1 Qualitative analysis of the in-depth interview … … … … 59
4.5.2 Status of registration of the ten (10) companies … … … … 59
4.5.3 Period of operation in the state … … … … … … 60
4.5.4 Personnel capacity of the companies … … … … … 60
4.5.5 Does your company have a training school … … … … 60
4.5.6 Running refreshers courses on security tips for the personnel … … 61
4.5.7 Sills impacted during workshops and seminars … … … … 61
4.5.8 Cars/motorcycles for patrols … … … … … … 61
4.5.9 Duration for promotion of staff … … … … … … 61
4.5.16 Relationship of PSCs with Nigeria police … … … 64
4.5.17 Prosecution of cases in court … … … … 64
4.5.18 Suggestions for overcoming the constraints … 64
CHAPTER FIVE: SUMMARY, RECOMMENDATIONS AND SUGGESTION FOR FUTURE STUDIES
5.1 Summary … … … … … … … … 66
5.2 Recommendation … … … … … … … 67
5.3 Suggestions for future studies … … … … … … 68
References … … … … … … … … … 69
Appendix 1 … … … … … … … … … 73
Appendix 2 … … … … … … … …. … 76
Appendix 3 … … … … … … … … … 78
Appendix 4 … … … … … … … … … 79
Appendix 5 … … … … … … … … … 80
Appendix 6 … … … … … … … … … 81
Appendix 7 … … … … … … … … … 82
Appendix 8 … … … … … … … … … 83
ACRONYMS
| CIA: | Criminal Intelligence Agency | |
| EIU: | Economic Intelligence Unit | |
| FCE: | Federal College of Education | |
| GRA: | Government Reservation Area |
| LGAs: | Local Government Areas | |
| NA: | Native Authority | |
| NCE: | Nigeria Certificate of Education | |
| ND: | National Diploma |
NSCDC: Nigeria Security and Civil Defense Corps
| PGCs: | Private Guard Companies | |
| PMFs: | Private Military Forces | |
| PSC: | Private Security Company | |
| PSCS: | Private Security Companies | |
| PSG: | Private Security Guard | |
| SPSS: | Statistical Package for Social Sciences | |
| SSCE: | Senior Secondary Certificate Examination |
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background to the Study
Human history has always been punctuated with societal concern for security at both the individual and collective levels. This has particularly been the case because security affects people’s livelihood. The privatization of security has now become a global phenomenon (Hyden, 1995). This is the result of a number of factors including general human insecurity, the globalization phenomenon, the privatization of public enterprises, the professionalization of armed and police forces, drive for profit maximization, liberalization of the arms trade, general unending African conflict and the crashing of the twin towers and the pentagon on the 11th of September, 2001 in United States (Holmqvist, 2005). In the contemporary world, the privatization of security has spread throughout the world to an unprecedented level that it is no longer possible to ignore, let alone comprehend (Howe, 1998).
The many types of modern private security outfits available today may be traced to Allan
Pinkerton, who founded Pinkerton’s security services in 1850 with the motto “we never sleep”
(Schmalleger, 1995). It was also the largest of the private firms headquartered in New York. The Pinkerton Service had a logo which was an open eye, to signify constant vigilance on its office doors. The term “private eye” is thought to have developed from the use of this logo. In another development, Schmalleger (1995) affirmed that Henry Wells and William Fargo built their popularly known Wells Fargo company in 1852 and supplied detective and protective services (private guard and investigator) to areas of West of Missouri.
Thus, much has changed since the early days of private security firms (private policing).
Today, services are provided for hospitals, manufacturing plants, communication industries, retirement homes, hotels, casinos, exclusive communities and clubs. Others are nuclear storage facilities and reactors, and many other types of businesses such as information security that aid the protection of personnel.
Following a history of private guards and security practice in Nigeria which could be traced to royalty, religion, social class or pedigree; the practice of private security gradually attracted a deserved attention when it became commercialized and obviously conflicted with the social contract idea which states that only the state is capable of arrest and punishment (Kuna, 1999). Thus, it became imperative that the practice had to be regulated within the confines of duty, definition and laws. For instance, security in the traditional Nigerian society squarely lay with the immediate and extended families; hence any member of the family that violates any of the norms was in danger of being ostracized by the group until reparations and necessary purification and cleansing rituals were undertaken by the family (Igbo, 2007).
Thus, changes have taken place from the traditional Nigerian societies to the present as a result of ‘modernisation’. These changes occasioned the encroachment of western institutions on moral standards of the society which has implications for general life and security particularly on
Nigerians. Other factors include urbanization, formal education and capitalist economic system. As a result a range of crimes emanated quite different from what was known in the traditional society, which may require more sophisticated security approach. Some of these crimes include murder, theft, assault, and suicide, pick pocketing, drug abuse, counterfeiting, fraud, forgery, smuggling, unlawful possession of dangerous weapons, prostitution, white- collar crime, advanced fee fraud (419) corruption, rape, and a host of others which are all prevalent in modern
Nigeria(Ebbe, 1981 cited in Igbo, 2007).
Thus, Ochefu and Idrees (2002), posited that, the Nupes and Gwagyis who are predominant groups in Abuja Municipal with migrant Hausas’ prevent crimes through proper socialization of the young ones i.e application of communal approach to socialization, instilling of the fear of pain in punishment…later, other prevention measures include the organization of the Dogarai (local police), the Ninety (90) days cleansing fast as reparation; Others include the use of scarecrows, charms and fetish materials and the use of Ndakogboya or Kuti (Masquerade) popularly known among the Nupes.
Also, according to Igbo (2007), the end of the civil war witnessed not only the return of old criminals to the street; but also the ‘graduation’ of new and more sophisticated ones’. This singular assertion indicates that the current state of security network in the country may be under serious threat as crime waves continue to rise unabated.
The most recent of the threats to security in Nigeria is the emergence of kidnapping and terrorism which have been enhanced by the widespread use of firearms by criminals. This indeed facilitated the modus operandi of these criminals, thereby enhancing complete change in criminal activities as cases of aircraft hijacking and assassinations of prominent Nigerians and bomb explosions in various corners of the country became rampant.
In addition to earlier mentioned criminal activities, today law and order also pose serious security challenges in the country. According to Sunday Ehindaro, the former Inspector General of Police, “perhaps the most potent threat to national security of any country is crime”
(Dambazau, 2007: 152). This statement is also in line with the report of the Economic
Intelligence Unit (EIU) in a survey called “RISKWIRE” which concluded that,
Nigeria is an insecure environment for commercial operations. Security risk arises at three levels. The first comes from rising violent crime (from) simple armed robbery (to) carjacking and violent attacks….Second, companies can be subjected to direct attack or blackmail…facilities can be vandalized and staff kidnapped. Third, incidences of inter-communal violence have risen… Nigeria’s ill equipped police force … has been ineffective in stemming the crime wave. (Dambazau, 2007: 53).
Therefore, the ineffectiveness of the Nigeria police and the concern of Nigerians for security led to the emergence of guards and private security companies in the country to augment the activities of the security agencies and work in line with the laid down rules and regulations. Just like the vigilante, private security companies are also an informal arrangement to keep with the pace of rising crime rate in Nigeria.
However, as is the case in all countries, the citizens of Nigeria are highly concerned about their security and this concern has been expressed through the growth of Private Security Companies (PSCs). The last decade has seen a proliferation of PSCs in a country of about 140 million people (Census, 2006). The presence of these companies is conspicuous in the premises of both private and public sector organizations. This is in spite of the fact that in both urban and rural areas, security matters are largely in the hands of private actors than in those of the state. Thus, the function of private security companies was handled by the Nigeria immigration service in the Federal Ministry of Interior. Until 1st September, 2005 when the then Minister of Internal Affairs handed over all documents of private guard companies to the Nigeria Security and Civil Defense Corps (NSCDC, 2009).
There are two principal landmarks in the regulation of PSCs in Nigeria. The first is the enactment and approval for creation of PSCs on 15th December 1986. This law was cited as Act No 43 and consolidated under the laws of the Federation of Nigeria 1990 in chapter 367. The second is the handover from the Nigeria immigration service to Nigeria civil defense corps cited currently as chapter 30 in Private Guard Companies (PGC) Act (Laws of the Federation of
Nigeria, 2004). This law is specifically enacted for the “regulation and licensing of private guard companies which must be wholly owned by Nigerians and other matters-ancillary thereto” (PGCs Act, Cap367, 1990).
Finally, the perception of ineffective policing and rising crime gave impetus to the emergence of a plethora of non-state policing groups (Olaniyi, 2005). The state has shared its security responsibility with a variety of non-political organizations including vigilante groups, religious vigilante, ethnic militias and private security guards.
Based on the above and most especially considering its growing importance, the activities of the PSCs necessarily became a subject of study. This has led the researcher to the choice of private security companies and crime prevention in Nigeria with Abuja Municipal as a case study.
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Law, order and security were maintained in the pre-colonial societies through thorough socialization of members of the society using peer group, age grade and religious institutions (Ogunbameru and Rotimi, 2006). Thus, violators of societal norms, customs, and traditions of various communal groups faced serious sanctions which ranged from ostracizing, payment of reparation and purification and consequently the performing of cleansing rituals (Igbo, 2007). For instance in Abuja Municipal, criminals pay for their crimes through serving various punishment such as digging of dungeons, working in the Emir’s farm, quarrying, and in cases which involve witchcraft and murder, banishment or ninety (90) days cleansing fast was observed as reparation (Idrees and Ochefu, 2002). The occurrence of these crimes was often at a lower rate because these sanctions also helped in inducing fear into the people on the negative consequences of committing crime in the society.
These roles changed during the colonial era following the introduction of formal social control. The Native Authority (NA) police assumed the role of maintaining law, order and security, while the citizens simply became on-lookers because community security was seen as the responsibility of the government. At this point, insecurity also started growing due to the nature of native administration. This is because Nationalist activities were seen and conceived of as an attack on the colonialists (Kuna, 1999). Therefore, the brutality of the NA police became instrumental to the growth of the nationalist movement at this time in the society.
During the post-colonial era, especially after the civil war in Nigeria, the activities of criminals grew almost out of hand as a result of the proliferation of firearms which were found in all nooks and crannies of the country. This hastened the growth of crime on the one hand, and also brought about the need to further secure the urban communities where robbery and the nefarious acts of criminals were frequent. Therefore, urban areas like Lagos, Ibadan, Enugu, and
Kano started having neighborhood guards due to the inefficiency of the police (Dambazau, 2007; Igbo, 2007)
In describing insecurity in Nigerian urban cities, Osahon (1996 in Dogon-yaro, 1996)
stated that:
Actually we are under severe siege already as a people. Fear now rules our daily lives. Ugly, harrowing fear of the known and unknown. When we go out in the mornings, we are not sure we will return home safely and with our cars and other property including even the shoes on our feet or the earring in our ears. If we are lucky to arrive to find our homes unraided in our absence, we sleep with one eye open expecting the worst any moment of the night. In other words, we do not sleep any more… in our ability to perform daily activities (Dogon-yaro, 1996:224).
This situation also existed in other growing cities in Abuja Municipal such as Minna, Kontagora, Bida, Suleja, and a few other towns. The public response to perpetual fear and insecurity was to take laws into its own hands. In July 1987, butchers, traders, and unemployed persons in Minna vented their wrath over police harassment, intimidation, and extortion in a sixhour rampage against police and soldiers that was quelled by military units (The library of Congress Country Studies and CIA Factbook, 1991).
Again, in May, 2009, two lecturers from School of Nursing Bida were bathed with acid in their staff quarters by students suspected to have been withdrawn by the institution for having failed in all their first semester examinations. It was noted that the staff quarters lacked security guards unlike the school premises and the culprits were not apprehended (Sunday Trust, May 17, 2009). However, in July, 2009, Newline news paper reported that, the family of one Mr. James Omeize, the proprietor of Brighter International School in Minna was kidnapped in Minna and the kidnapper demanded 20 million naira for his release in far away Benin City in Edo state.
Other insecurity instances abound in the state as many cases are not even reported to the police or captured by any vigilant watch dog. The Nigeria police has always came under severe criticism; being accused of falling victims to every negative unfavourable character, devoid of any measure commensurate to their oath of office. In other words, this weakened capacity of the Nigeria Police to fight crime (i.e shortage of staff, obsolete equipment, corruption, defective training programmes, police discretion etc) has led to increase in other policing agencies across the country over the years. It is due to the importance attached to security of lives and property that both the professional and non-professional security outfits came into existence in these urban centres.
After about two decades of the flourishing of private security industry in Abuja Municipal, it appears PSCs have not received much scholarly attention in terms of the services they provide. One wonders if the seeming increase in the number of private security companies in Abuja Municipal is caused by the desire for improved security or other ulterior motives. It is in the light of the above problems, that this research work is aimed at examining the private security companies in Abuja Municipal.
1.3 Research Questions
The following research questions are formulated to guide the study:-
- How were the security needs of the people in Abuja Municipal provided during the traditional era?
- What factors necessitated the establishment of PSCs?
- How effective are these PSCs in their security functions?
- What are their major constraints in carrying out these functions?
- What are the strategies for overcoming these constraints in order to make them more
efficient?
- What is the relationship between PSCs and the Police?
1.4 Research Objectives
The general objective of this research is to determine how effective private security companies are in crime prevention in Abuja Municipal.
The following are the specific objectives of the research;
- To find out how security needs of people in Abuja Municipal were provided during the
traditional era.
- To determine the factors that necessitated the establishment of PSCs
- To assess the effectiveness of these PSCs in their security functions
- To examine the major constraints of the PSCs in carrying out their functions.
- To identify the strategies for overcoming their constraints for efficient service delivery.
- To examine the relationship between PSCs and the Police
1.5 Significance of the Study
This study has both theoretical and practical significance.
- Theoretical significance: this study will contribute to existing literature on PSCs/PSGs especially in the area of crime prevention in Nigeria. The study will also provide the baseline information on typologies of crime prevention in Abuja Municipal and stimulate research in the field by other researchers and academicians. Moreover, the study will provide reference document to other scholars who want to engage in studies of PSCs and crime prevention.
- Practical significance: the findings of this study will enhance the understanding of policy makers on strategies and dynamics of crime prevention companies. This will lead to a design of programmes that will enhance crime prevention and improve security of lives and property in Abuja Municipal. This study is also significant for the fact that the findings will assist in extending and deepening the understanding of policy makers to improve crime prevention through the PSCs. This will reveal, if any, the challenges of working with wide range of Private Security Companies and provide suggestions on how the challenges identified can be overcome.
1.6 Operationalisation of Concepts
The following terms are used in this research and are defined based on their usage in this context. Beneficiaries: Refers to individuals, private and public enterprises, ministries, agencies, directorates etc who subscribes to the services of the PSCs.
Crime: Refers to wrongdoing that threatens the security or well-being of society and usually considered an act (evil) punishable by law.
Crime Prevention: It refers to a pattern of attitudes and behaviours directed both at reducing the threat of crime and enhancing the sense of safety and security to positively influence the quality of life…and to develop environments where crime cannot flourish
Formal Security Sector: Refers to police and the army which the constitution of a country formally recognizes for the defense, peace, total security and integrity of the country.
National Security: Refers to safeguarding the interest of the citizenry and providing the type of atmosphere that is free of threats that could inhibit the pursuit of the good of all. It is about the processes and measures required to preserve law and order.
Private Security: Refers to those self-employed individuals and privately funded business entities and organizations providing security –related services to specific clientele for a fee, for the individual or entity that retains or employs them, for themselves, in order to protect their persons, private property or interests from various hazards.
Private Policing: This refers to the performance of policing functions by individuals or agencies other than those directly owned and controlled by the state.
Security: This means protection from physical or direct violence, and freedom from fear; a sense of safety and relative wellbeing in political, legal, socio-economic and cultural terms, it is also, a measure of protection from structural violence and security of lives and properties as enshrined in the constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.
HOW TO RECEIVE PROJECT MATERIAL(S)
After paying the appropriate amount (#5,000) into our bank Account below, send the following information to
08068231953 or 08168759420
(1) Your project topics
(2) Email Address
(3) Payment Name
(4) Teller Number
We will send your material(s) after we receive bank alert
BANK ACCOUNTS
Account Name: AMUTAH DANIEL CHUKWUDI
Account Number: 0046579864
Bank: GTBank.
OR
Account Name: AMUTAH DANIEL CHUKWUDI
Account Number: 3139283609
Bank: FIRST BANK
FOR MORE INFORMATION, CALL:
08068231953 or 08168759420